No Comment
The mayor changed the citizen comment rules for the July 27, 2006 council meeting. The Sentinel covered this well and the meeting was packed with concerned citizens. As presiding officer of the meeting, the mayor is responsible for conducting the meeting productively. Unfortunately, he thinks he can also make up the rules of the meeting. The rules should reflect the consensus of council, not one person. During the previous meeting, I tried to make a comment after the mayor had finished his mayor's report. As many of you know, the mayor likes to bury controversial items such as the landfill in this report so that they do not show up on the agenda. The Texas Attorney General has specifically commented on such actions and believes they are illegal (see TML Handbook, ch. 5)
When I raised my hand to be recognized, the mayor refused to let me comment telling me I could only speak during citizen comment period. I read him the rules for that very meeting that clearly stated that citizens are invited to comment on any agenda item at the time the item is discussed. After rereading his agenda the mayor allowed me to speak though it seemed to cause him much displeasure. I asked him to please put the landfill subject on the agenda in the future so that citizens would know in advance that it was to be discussed. This same comment had been made by another citizen in the preceding meeting.
As I sat down, the thought occurred to me that the mayor would try to change the rules for the next meeting. Sure enough.
Once again, the mayor has attempted to grab power that has not been given to the mayor's office. The city council meeting is the place for councilmembers to conduct business. Once rules are established, the mayor enforces the meeting rules. This is not the same as making the rules. The mayor seems confused here. The proper procedure for changing the meeting rules is to place the issue on the agenda and discuss it with council to determine majority will.
Let me draw an analogy. The mayor thinks he can make the rules because his job is to enforce the meeting rules. This is comparable to a police officer believing that he can make the laws when his job is to enforce the laws.
It is interesting to note that the rule change was proposed for the meeting where the mayor was trying to have Betsy Burns put in an official position to make recommendations about changes to P&Z and BoA. The mayor had already informed us that he wanted those two boards dissolved and consolidated under Betsy Burns. How convenient if he could eliminate citizen comments during this discussion. This P&Z BoA topic deserves more discussion.
Marfa does not have much in the way of resolutions for ways to conduct business. Before this mayor, the relationship between city hall and city council was more cooperative and less divisive. Respect, common sense and consideration were sufficient. We now have a power-hungry mayor and have reached a point where written rules are necessary.
When I raised my hand to be recognized, the mayor refused to let me comment telling me I could only speak during citizen comment period. I read him the rules for that very meeting that clearly stated that citizens are invited to comment on any agenda item at the time the item is discussed. After rereading his agenda the mayor allowed me to speak though it seemed to cause him much displeasure. I asked him to please put the landfill subject on the agenda in the future so that citizens would know in advance that it was to be discussed. This same comment had been made by another citizen in the preceding meeting.
As I sat down, the thought occurred to me that the mayor would try to change the rules for the next meeting. Sure enough.
Once again, the mayor has attempted to grab power that has not been given to the mayor's office. The city council meeting is the place for councilmembers to conduct business. Once rules are established, the mayor enforces the meeting rules. This is not the same as making the rules. The mayor seems confused here. The proper procedure for changing the meeting rules is to place the issue on the agenda and discuss it with council to determine majority will.
Let me draw an analogy. The mayor thinks he can make the rules because his job is to enforce the meeting rules. This is comparable to a police officer believing that he can make the laws when his job is to enforce the laws.
It is interesting to note that the rule change was proposed for the meeting where the mayor was trying to have Betsy Burns put in an official position to make recommendations about changes to P&Z and BoA. The mayor had already informed us that he wanted those two boards dissolved and consolidated under Betsy Burns. How convenient if he could eliminate citizen comments during this discussion. This P&Z BoA topic deserves more discussion.
Marfa does not have much in the way of resolutions for ways to conduct business. Before this mayor, the relationship between city hall and city council was more cooperative and less divisive. Respect, common sense and consideration were sufficient. We now have a power-hungry mayor and have reached a point where written rules are necessary.
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home