Sauceda's Bonus
Council member Martinez took action Thursday night on Administrator Sauceda's year-end bonus that was possibly illegally authorized for the second year in a row by Mayor Lanman. Big Bend Sentinel readers may have seen my letter to the editor on this subject Thursday morning. This unauthorized perk was discovered through the participants of this blog.
Martinez said, "Where I stand on this vacation sales, I have always been opposed to it. Council has never done anything about this. It is in the policy manual, I have stated before that this is not good policy. As far as the administrator selling back his time, I want you to ask legal advice if this policy applies to the administrator as other employees. If it is against policy or is in error or illegal, the administrator needs to pay it back. I need some sort of determination for the next meeting to present it in public."
To summarize: Employees are allowed in the current policy manual to sell their vacation back to the city for cash instead of taking the vacation. Employees are required to get supervisor authorization in writing for these vacation sales. Sauceda's Employment Contract (big scanned PDF file!) says, "The employee shall be entitled to the same benefits as all other salaried City employees, including but not limited to, earned vacation..." He is entitled to ask to sell his vacation back to the city, that much is probably true.
I have heard rumors that Sauceda has encouraged other employees to sell their vacation before the rules get changed by council. I can only assume he is encouraging further waste of public funds so that his abuse does not stand out. Can council investigate this?
Sauceda's contract started in February 2005. In August 2005, after Lanman and Sauceda dropped their threatened lawsuits over death threats, Sauceda and Council Member Dobay were asked by council to evaluate Sauceda's salary after he had been with the city six months. The expectation was that they would come back to the council with a recommendation based on some sound justifications. Instead, Lanman and Dobay gave Sauceda a 25 percent raise without discussing it with council. Sauceda should have known that council must approve these changes. Did he take the matter to council? No, he simply instructed staff to fatten his paycheck immediately. Council was hopping mad, and they let Lanman know he was out of order. Somewhat embarrassed, they authorized his sweet pay raise after he had already started collecting it.
Jump ahead to December 2005. The city failed to pass the 05-06 budget until October 19, 2005, nineteen days too late. State law does not allow property tax hikes if the city does not adopt a budget before the fiscal year started. Oops. The city's finances are a mess. What does Sauceda do? He sells one week of vacation in December and then takes a week off. He gets two weeks like everybody else. Did he use his vacation time for his travel days? Nope. He travelled on the clock and saved his vacation days to cash in at the end of the year. Who authorized that? Council did not.
Jump ahead to December 2006. The council finally passes the 06-07 budget on December 12, two and a half month late. Once again, property taxes cannot be raised. The city is in a "budget crisis" according to Martinez. What does Sauceda do? He sells another week of vacation to the city and collects double-pay for the week. Who authorized it? Mayor David Lanman. This of course begs the question, was this expense in the budget? If it was in the budget, did council know that this fat existed and could be cut out? If it was not in the budget, what in the hell was David Lanman doing spending money not in the budget?
I asked Sauceda who authorized the vacation sale. He said, "the mayor." I asked him what authority the mayor had to authorize this expense. He said, "He's the CEO of Marfa." I reminded him of something he had told me months before, he reports to the collective city council and not the mayor. The employee manual requires supervisor authorization for vacation sales. David Lanman is not the supervisor; city council is Sauceda's supervisor. David Lanman has no authority to authorize this expense. In fact, the mayor has no authority to spend any money without approval. Remember the $3,000 door that Lanman bought? He had no right to authorize that purchase. So Sauceda covered for him and authorized it. Of course it was not in the budget, so not even Sauceda had the right to authorize it. But that's another story.
I did a little research on mayor as CEO. Anybody interested in Marfa politics here would be wise to read Local Government Code Chapter 22 Aldermanic Form of Government in a Type A General-Law Municipality. Look at the first two lines under Powers and Duties of the Mayor in 22.042:
But wait, who are the officers? Later on in 22.071 we find, "In addition to the members of the governing body (city council) of the municipality, the other officers of the municipality are the secretary, treasurer, assessor and collector, municipal attorney, marshal, municipal engineer, and any other officers or agents authorized by the governing body." That raises lots of questions about who all these officers are, but look at the last part of that: "any other officers or agents authorized" by the city council. Who could that be?
Well, take a look at Ordinance 01-02 (large scanned PDF file!) that authorizes the "position and office of City Administrator" pursuant to 22.071. The term "Chief Administrative Officer" is actually used in the first WHEREAS sentence. So Sauceda is an officer (and a gentleman). As CEO, Lanman is required by law to inspect the conduct of subordinate officers and cause prosecution for negligence, carelessness or violation of duty!
This is really funny. Sauceda claims that Lanman has power to authorize vacation sales because he is CEO. The truth is the opposite! Lanman is required by law to cause prosecution and punishment for situations involving misuse of public funds by other city officers! David should not be giving Flo tax dollars, he should be calling the district attorney and demanding an investigation of himself and Flo!
I am happy that Councilmember Martinez is demanding a report and accountability. It is high time that council investigate the shenanigans going on with tax dollars between Officers Lanman and Sauceda. Now let's see how this plays out. I predict that Sauceda will call Monte Akers and get a verbal report. He will ask Monte if the administrator is allowed to sell back vacation like any other employee. Monte will affirm this because it is legal. Flo will not ask Monte if David has the power to authorize it. He will not ask Monte if the last two vacation sales have been legal. He will return to council and give a verbal report, like usual, that the city attorney has reviewed it and said it is A-OK.
If he does this, council should fire Sauceda on the spot. At will. For cause. By motion, second and public vote. So be it.
[Oops, I forgot that Sauceda would need to put his termination on the agenda before council could fire him!]
The only proper way for this to be handled is for Monte Akers to provide a written and public response to the following questions:
Who in Marfa paid $2,500 in property taxes so that Mayor David Lanman could give it to Administrator Florencio Sauceda as year-end bonuses behind closed doors without proper authorization?
Let me put this in real tax dollars. How much property tax does it take to pay Sauceda an extra $1250 plus some payroll tax? The tax rate is 58 cents per $100 with 24 cents going to debt and 34 cents going to the general fund. Let's assume an average property value on the tax rolls of $45,000 ($50M total value divided by 1100 utility accounts). The average homeowner will pay $261 in property tax with $108 going to debt and $153 going to the general fund. All of the available property tax for more then eight homes is required just to pay this bonus for Sauceda! Are you one of those eight homeowners? Are you mad yet?
Is Budget Officer Lanman or Chief Administrative Officer Sauceda aware that this city is in financial trouble? If they are aware of this, then why do they conspire behind closed doors to pad Sauceda's salary with our tax dollars? Even if Monte finds a way to declare it legal to save the hide of the person paying his bills, is it right?
The money is one thing. Certainly the city wastes more than this amount regularly. (Have you seen Monte's bills caused by Sauceda and Lanman calling him for every little issue?) The real violation of trust is the way that Lanman uses tax money to buy the support of Sauceda. They are both complicit. The administrator reports to council and serves council (and serves at the will of council I remind you). But when Lanman uses our money to pay Sauceda, he upsets the balance of power. Suddenly, Sauceda owes a favor back to Lanman. Does he think about this when he makes the council's agenda? If Lanman wants something on agenda, or not on agenda, or the agenda order switched around, is Sauceda more likely to obey Lanman after Lanman has authorized one big pay raise and two bonuses without council approval? What do you think?
Martinez said, "Where I stand on this vacation sales, I have always been opposed to it. Council has never done anything about this. It is in the policy manual, I have stated before that this is not good policy. As far as the administrator selling back his time, I want you to ask legal advice if this policy applies to the administrator as other employees. If it is against policy or is in error or illegal, the administrator needs to pay it back. I need some sort of determination for the next meeting to present it in public."
To summarize: Employees are allowed in the current policy manual to sell their vacation back to the city for cash instead of taking the vacation. Employees are required to get supervisor authorization in writing for these vacation sales. Sauceda's Employment Contract (big scanned PDF file!) says, "The employee shall be entitled to the same benefits as all other salaried City employees, including but not limited to, earned vacation..." He is entitled to ask to sell his vacation back to the city, that much is probably true.
I have heard rumors that Sauceda has encouraged other employees to sell their vacation before the rules get changed by council. I can only assume he is encouraging further waste of public funds so that his abuse does not stand out. Can council investigate this?
Sauceda's contract started in February 2005. In August 2005, after Lanman and Sauceda dropped their threatened lawsuits over death threats, Sauceda and Council Member Dobay were asked by council to evaluate Sauceda's salary after he had been with the city six months. The expectation was that they would come back to the council with a recommendation based on some sound justifications. Instead, Lanman and Dobay gave Sauceda a 25 percent raise without discussing it with council. Sauceda should have known that council must approve these changes. Did he take the matter to council? No, he simply instructed staff to fatten his paycheck immediately. Council was hopping mad, and they let Lanman know he was out of order. Somewhat embarrassed, they authorized his sweet pay raise after he had already started collecting it.
Jump ahead to December 2005. The city failed to pass the 05-06 budget until October 19, 2005, nineteen days too late. State law does not allow property tax hikes if the city does not adopt a budget before the fiscal year started. Oops. The city's finances are a mess. What does Sauceda do? He sells one week of vacation in December and then takes a week off. He gets two weeks like everybody else. Did he use his vacation time for his travel days? Nope. He travelled on the clock and saved his vacation days to cash in at the end of the year. Who authorized that? Council did not.
Jump ahead to December 2006. The council finally passes the 06-07 budget on December 12, two and a half month late. Once again, property taxes cannot be raised. The city is in a "budget crisis" according to Martinez. What does Sauceda do? He sells another week of vacation to the city and collects double-pay for the week. Who authorized it? Mayor David Lanman. This of course begs the question, was this expense in the budget? If it was in the budget, did council know that this fat existed and could be cut out? If it was not in the budget, what in the hell was David Lanman doing spending money not in the budget?
I asked Sauceda who authorized the vacation sale. He said, "the mayor." I asked him what authority the mayor had to authorize this expense. He said, "He's the CEO of Marfa." I reminded him of something he had told me months before, he reports to the collective city council and not the mayor. The employee manual requires supervisor authorization for vacation sales. David Lanman is not the supervisor; city council is Sauceda's supervisor. David Lanman has no authority to authorize this expense. In fact, the mayor has no authority to spend any money without approval. Remember the $3,000 door that Lanman bought? He had no right to authorize that purchase. So Sauceda covered for him and authorized it. Of course it was not in the budget, so not even Sauceda had the right to authorize it. But that's another story.
I did a little research on mayor as CEO. Anybody interested in Marfa politics here would be wise to read Local Government Code Chapter 22 Aldermanic Form of Government in a Type A General-Law Municipality. Look at the first two lines under Powers and Duties of the Mayor in 22.042:
- The mayor is the chief executive officer of the municipality. The mayor shall at all times actively ensure that the laws and ordinances of the municipality are properly carried out. The mayor shall perform the duties and exercise the powers prescribed by the governing body of the municipality.
- The mayor shall inspect the conduct of each subordinate municipal officer and shall cause any negligence, carelessness, or other violation of duty to be prosecuted and punished.
But wait, who are the officers? Later on in 22.071 we find, "In addition to the members of the governing body (city council) of the municipality, the other officers of the municipality are the secretary, treasurer, assessor and collector, municipal attorney, marshal, municipal engineer, and any other officers or agents authorized by the governing body." That raises lots of questions about who all these officers are, but look at the last part of that: "any other officers or agents authorized" by the city council. Who could that be?
Well, take a look at Ordinance 01-02 (large scanned PDF file!) that authorizes the "position and office of City Administrator" pursuant to 22.071. The term "Chief Administrative Officer" is actually used in the first WHEREAS sentence. So Sauceda is an officer (and a gentleman). As CEO, Lanman is required by law to inspect the conduct of subordinate officers and cause prosecution for negligence, carelessness or violation of duty!
This is really funny. Sauceda claims that Lanman has power to authorize vacation sales because he is CEO. The truth is the opposite! Lanman is required by law to cause prosecution and punishment for situations involving misuse of public funds by other city officers! David should not be giving Flo tax dollars, he should be calling the district attorney and demanding an investigation of himself and Flo!
I am happy that Councilmember Martinez is demanding a report and accountability. It is high time that council investigate the shenanigans going on with tax dollars between Officers Lanman and Sauceda. Now let's see how this plays out. I predict that Sauceda will call Monte Akers and get a verbal report. He will ask Monte if the administrator is allowed to sell back vacation like any other employee. Monte will affirm this because it is legal. Flo will not ask Monte if David has the power to authorize it. He will not ask Monte if the last two vacation sales have been legal. He will return to council and give a verbal report, like usual, that the city attorney has reviewed it and said it is A-OK.
If he does this, council should fire Sauceda on the spot. At will. For cause. By motion, second and public vote. So be it.
[Oops, I forgot that Sauceda would need to put his termination on the agenda before council could fire him!]
The only proper way for this to be handled is for Monte Akers to provide a written and public response to the following questions:
- Is the city administrator allowed to sell vacation time back to the city?
- Who must authorize this financial transaction?
- Does the mayor have this authority? (with legal references as needed)
- Were the last two vacation sales by Sauceda legal?
- Is this a misuse of public funds?
- Does it need to be repaid to avoid prosecution?
- Can it be prosecuted even if repaid?
Who in Marfa paid $2,500 in property taxes so that Mayor David Lanman could give it to Administrator Florencio Sauceda as year-end bonuses behind closed doors without proper authorization?
Let me put this in real tax dollars. How much property tax does it take to pay Sauceda an extra $1250 plus some payroll tax? The tax rate is 58 cents per $100 with 24 cents going to debt and 34 cents going to the general fund. Let's assume an average property value on the tax rolls of $45,000 ($50M total value divided by 1100 utility accounts). The average homeowner will pay $261 in property tax with $108 going to debt and $153 going to the general fund. All of the available property tax for more then eight homes is required just to pay this bonus for Sauceda! Are you one of those eight homeowners? Are you mad yet?
Is Budget Officer Lanman or Chief Administrative Officer Sauceda aware that this city is in financial trouble? If they are aware of this, then why do they conspire behind closed doors to pad Sauceda's salary with our tax dollars? Even if Monte finds a way to declare it legal to save the hide of the person paying his bills, is it right?
The money is one thing. Certainly the city wastes more than this amount regularly. (Have you seen Monte's bills caused by Sauceda and Lanman calling him for every little issue?) The real violation of trust is the way that Lanman uses tax money to buy the support of Sauceda. They are both complicit. The administrator reports to council and serves council (and serves at the will of council I remind you). But when Lanman uses our money to pay Sauceda, he upsets the balance of power. Suddenly, Sauceda owes a favor back to Lanman. Does he think about this when he makes the council's agenda? If Lanman wants something on agenda, or not on agenda, or the agenda order switched around, is Sauceda more likely to obey Lanman after Lanman has authorized one big pay raise and two bonuses without council approval? What do you think?
15 Comments:
I was quite concerned upon learning of Mr. Sauceda's newest year-end bonus. There are very few people who live and work in Marfa making more than Mr. Sauceda (of course some might argue that he neither lives nor works here!). The rest of us work hard for our incomes, pay our taxes respectfully, expecting those hard earned tax dollars to at least be spent with the utmost consideration for propriety and honesty.
But no, it seems that Lanman and Sauceda are playing fast and loose with other people's money. They buy new cameras, police cars and glass doors, take "investigative" trips, and now give/take questionable bonuses--all while moaning about the need for increased revenues from the rest of us.
The two of them haven't been able to muster even a modest tax increase for the past two years. To make up for their incompetence, they engineer other ways to soak us so that they can continue to be irresponsible with public monies. Now we have the EMS/Fire increase, the possible $5.00-$10.00 addition to our sewer bills to pay for the new waste water facility, an increase on our electric bills due to an increase of AEP's franchise fee, and on and on.
Suddenly, with the information in this latest posting, the realization comes that I could have easily been one of those eight home owners whose hard earned property taxes did not go to finance the city services we all expect our city to be providing for us, but instead went to fund yet another special deal between Lanman and Sauceda.
Please help us out here, Council. We have elected you and expect you to protect, as well as thoughtfully spend, those tax dollars we collectively entrust to you. Thank you for asking the city attorney to look into this matter, Oscar. Thank you, Council, for your leadership here.
Why-Why are they, the council, thinking of giving Sauceda a contract! What possible benefit is it to us,the taxpayers, for him to have a contract? Is it some-sort-of blackmail.."Give me a contract and I will move here"?.. or--"I will do a better job".... "I will give you $65,000. worth of work"
It seems a contract has about a $25,000 downside, if come May we get a reasonable Mayor and the makeup of the council is unbiased we the tax payer will be facing a huge severance package. How many homes worth of property taxes will that take?
What is the math?...30 some?
If a contract is sooo important why not wait until after the elections?
Concur with Anon 11:17AM.
Bingo! There in only one difference between Sauceda having a contract and Sauceda not having a contract: his severance package. If Sauceda is terminated without a contract, he is only entitled to a severance package that council thinks appropriate. If he gets the terms of his old contract, he gets FIVE MONTHS SEVERANCE PAY even if fired for official misconduct!
At $65,000 a year, five months severance would cost the city $27,083. If I use the same tax assumptions used to calculate the impact of his bonus, it would take all of the annual property taxes from 177 households to pay him off.
This is not in the interest of Marfa. Sauceda has not earned this financial guarrantee from the citizens of Marfa.
I agree with Anon at 11:17AM. This city council has no ethical authority to give Sauceda a contract before the election. Sauceda has three supporters on council, two of them are on council as appointees without being elected into the current positions. One of those two is leaving Marfa in a matter of weeks and is busy packing the house up.
Council would be well advised to solicit opinions from as many citizens as possible before rewarding Sauceda's part-time lackadaisical service with a guarantee of our tax dollars. That would be financially irresponsible.
Boy was my math off, I thought property taxes from 30 homes would be outrageous but 177 ! Geeze! I have been trying to piece together what this high-dollar City Administrator has brought our city in the past two years. Something that stands out beyond what should be expected. I come up blank, maybe I don't know of the "well-worth-$65K" grants that he found." Or the smoothing of rocky personnel problems, or solving the fiscal issues. Either I don't know or he hasn't. Then I try too think of the innovative ideas he has brought from his $65K-bag-off-good-ideas. Innovation..lets see.. I remember his brilliant idea for a River Walk in the Alamito Creek...There has to be more..please post.
Don't you remember the James Dean replica car that he brought to town and sought funding for? I tell you, Marfa has never been the same since...
Sauceda is the CAUSE of "rocky personnel problems."
Speaking of the James Dean car fiasco, that was a portent of things to come. Flo still had charge of the city credit card and went and charged all kinds of refreshments at Town and County. He closed off the highways and main street without getting permission from TxDOT because he "knew somebody in Austin," there were expenditures for custom made EMBROIDERED Tshirts for him and his special friends, and on and on. Oh yeah, he supposedly arranged for a school bus to go down to Presidio to pick up folk dancers from OJ and hadn't bothered to see if they had the proper entry permission so the bus went down there and came back empty.
His vision was called Vista Marfa or Marfa Vista. He was going to dam up Alamito Creek and have a recreational water park out there with paddle boats and all.
And the council is going to give Flo another contract???
From an earlier blog:
City of Del Rio reasons for termination:
. Insubordination
• Impeding and obstructing requests for information from City Council members about administering finances.
• Failing to respond to requests for action, information, and written responses from City Council members.
• Failing to keep the City Council advised of the financial conditions and future needs of the City.
• Failing to carry out programs adopted by the council.
• Excessive absence from the city.
• Failing to follow and effectively implement the City’s adopted personnel policies and procedures guidelines and manual
• Exposing the city to possible liability by Manager’s statement and comments to non-employees about city employees
City of Taft:
According to the newspaper article written in Taft in November 2003, the Mayor stated that he and the council had discussed problems they had with him with Flo in executive sessions for “the better part of a year.” The Mayor further stated that Flo had missed 30 percent of the work year and routinely came to work at 11 a.m. or later and left around 3 p.m. He had been repeatedly warned to move to Taft from his home near Robstown and refused. The reasons listed for termination:
• Failing to respond to formulating programs to preserve Taft’s assets.
• Formulating public policy without consulting the council.
• Using city property and personnel inefficiently.
• Abusing the city’s sick leave and vacation policy.
That's all true and it is all happening again in Marfa! How does he get away with all that? Somebody on council sure does love him. More than they love Marfa?
Oscar and Gloria and Dan are rushing to give Flo a contract ASAP becaue all of their terms expire in May. These are Flo's supporters and only one was elected to their current position. Something stinks.
The latest: Rumor has it that the City put new tires on some city vehicle so Flo could make his trips home. Remember when Lanman, Saudeca, and Skiles all went to Austin in separate private cars to a meeting with the water board on the loan and all billed the city per diem and mileage? And Lanman was asked why they all had to take separate private vehicles and he said they couldn't trust the city car?
Did anybody ever find out what Skiles billed the city for that trip? I believe it was before he had been approved as the financial consultant on the project.
I am sure Skiles took that trip at his own expense. He makes money when he helps Marfa borrow money. Even though 40 percent of our property tax dollars go to repay debt, Skiles thinks we don't have enough debt. He thinks the way to fix our infrastructure is through bonds. He may be right. But when he stands to make money off the city's borrowing, it's hard to see him as objective. He is a professional, though he may not be independent.
IMHO, the best alternative for readers and posters to this blog is to consider a reform slate of candidates to run in the next election. As a not yet 24/7, 365 day a year resident (although I spent more than 180 days in 06 in Marfa, about the same as Flo), I really don't know who should be named to a reform slate.
Perhaps you folks have an idea that can gel into action. Rob has done this community one hell of a favor with this blog. Let's make something of it.
Thanks for the comment Mike. It's nice when people post with their name. I wish more people felt safer to use their names. People fear retruibution. That in itself is indicative a problem.
I am hearing encouraging things. People are thinking about running. Anybody could do a better job than Lanman. Council has not taken a leadership position for the most part. There have been refreshing exceptions.
In my opinion, we need a balanced council with members that know where Marfa has been and members who know from experience where Marfa is going. We need old-timers and newcomers to use trite labels.
What we really need is a council that understands the needs of the quiet majority of citizens that grew up here and the changes happening as Marfa changes rapidly into something else. In that way, we can try to shape the inevitable changes for the benefit of both old and new. To ignore what is really happening today is to fail to represent the needs of lifelong neighbors.
So I hope for a variety of people to toss their hats into the race. Mostly, we need people that want to lead Marfa through a difficult but unavoidable change. We cannot ignore the past.
I don't want anybody to be encouraged to run. I don't want a reform slate. I want to see natural leaders who have looked at this mess and say, "I can do better. I want to serve my neighbors as an elected official."
Check out today's BBS. Good editorial from Halpern.
The Mayor has lied again regarding the permitting process.
Florencio is trying to save his vacation booty.
Post a Comment
<< Home